CIL - Top Five Common Issues: Part 3 - Offset
Property Taxation - CIL Updates
CIL series to illustrate common issues
We set out in this article - the third of five - to highlight regular issues that we see on CIL projects across England & Wales, where Local Planning Authorities (LPAs) have adopted CIL This edition focuses on ‘Offset’.
What is CIL
Elsewhere on our website (or social media), you will find extensive narrative from us on the Community Infrastructure Levy, CIL. It was introduced within the Planning Act 2008 and came into effect under the Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations 2010 (as amended) - via periodic updates from published statutory instruments.
CIL generates valuable funding for the LPAs to help deliver new schools, surgeries or public facilities such as play areas, bus routes, etc. In essence the purpose is to provide social good for the local communities across the respective LPA.
Initially, CIL was expected to replace developers' contributions required via Section 106 of the Town & Country Planning Act 1990 (s.106). However, over time CIL has ended up running alongside s.106 so LPAs now effectively have two bites of the cherry, to help finance local infrastructure, necessitated by a scheme or project. Currently, there are 164 LPAs in England that have adopted CIL and 3 in Wales; it is not applicable to Scotland or Northern Ireland.
Offset to reduce CIL amount
‘Offset’ does not appear anywhere in the CIL Regulations 2010 (as amended). But it is the term given to the calculation of CIL that takes account of the ‘existing building(s)’ Gross Internal Area (GIA), used to reduce the quantum of the ‘proposed GIA’, or what the Regulations term ‘net chargeable area’ as set out in Schedule 1, Part 1, 1(4). Hence ‘offset’ is very important as one of the primary mechanisms to reduce the chargeable CIL on a new planning permission.
Offset only applies where there are existing buildings on the relevant land and can apply in three circumstances, for:
retained parts of ‘in-use’ buildings;
parts of ‘in-use’ buildings that are demolished under the scheme; and,
retained parts of buildings not requiring further planning permission.
The total proposed GIA is reduced by the sum of the allowable measured GIA of the three parts. If the existing GIA is greater than the proposed GIA and offset is available, then no CIL would result from the permission. But the CIL amount cannot be a negative, so any negative figure simply defaults to zero.
Unsurprisingly, as it has the potential to wipe out the CIL charge, Local Planning Authorities (LPAs) are extremely careful in their review of the planning application, approved drawings and associated documentation to seek out wording that paints a picture of disuse – or redundant and obsolete buildings. Unhelpfully for the landowners or developers, Schedule 1, Part 1, 1(8) or (9) enables LPAs to disregard “insufficient evidence”, or “evidence of insufficient quality” of any lawful use – deeming the existing building as not an in-use building, or that the retained part(s) GIA is nil; maximising the CIL calculation based upon the proposed GIA alone.
What is an "In-Use Building"?
The concept of the “in-use building” sits at the heart of most offset disputes. For a building to qualify, two principal requirements must be satisfied, as set out within Schedule 1, Part 1, 1(10):
First, the building must be a "relevant building". This requires the building to physically exist on the land subject to the planning permission (within the ‘redline’ drawing) at the date when planning permission first permits the development. Hence a building that has already been demolished before the relevant date of grant will not qualify
Secondly, the building(s) must contain “a part” that has been in lawful use for a continuous period of at least six months within the three-year period ending on the day planning permission first permits development.
This test appears straightforward but generates a considerable amount of debate as well as featuring in numerous Valuation Office (VO) CIL appeal decisions and recent litigation too.
The key elements are:
lawful use;
actual use;
continuous use;
at least six-months in duration, if not more; and
occurring within the relevant three-year reference period.
As with most aspects of CIL, it is an ‘all or nothing’ approach and so any failure on any one of these elements will result in the entire deduction being denied. Meaning the CIL figure may be higher than expected, or potentially incorrectly calculated.
The recent case of R (oao) Herod Property Ltd v Westminster City Council [2026] EWHC 2122 (Admin) left the developer liable for nearly £400,000 because they (and their planning agent) failed to take timely advice and engage with the LPA before commencing their project works. If they had acted in a timely manner, they could have been compliant with the relevant CIL Regulations and should have had zero CIL to pay on their change of use scheme converting offices to apartments, without any additional new GIA.
Please note, that for multiple existing buildings – each is considered in its own right for occupation, unless ancillary to another; e.g. outbuildings ancillary to a main dwelling are dependent on the occupation and use of the main dwelling.
Actual occupation
Unlike Business Ratings, where a valid lease has regularly been sufficient to attribute ‘use’ of the building, CIL cases are very specific that the burden of proof is to establish actual occupation of the property. Furthermore, that ‘use’ to facilitate ‘offset’ must be lawful – i.e. is a permitted existing planning use BEFORE the permission which is the subject of the CIL charge. During the Covid-19 pandemic this was problematic, depending upon use, as various LPAs challenged whether the use was continuous and thus sufficient to meet the criteria.
It is also important to demonstrate the actual use of the property, which is often difficult, particularly if owner-occupied as there is sometimes less evidence to prove the case – rarely a lease or rent payments. Each LPA has their own stance on how they manage the evidence required to prove that a building is ‘in-use’. The most common points of evidence acceptable to most LPAs are as follows:
Photographs (timestamped or dated)
Copies of leases and associated rent payments
Electricity/gas (or other utility) bills for a continuous six-month period (any submitted bills must show usage and not simply standing charges)
Business rate/council tax bills and payments. Note: The LPA CIL team does not have general access to this information as it is data protected
Confirmation from a letting agent/solicitor advising of the period of occupancy
Where an informal arrangement exists, redacted bank statements should be submitted to show rent has been paid
An affidavit/statutory declaration (a formal written statement signed before a notary)
Ideally, obtaining a number of these forms of evidence is preferrable – as the legal threshold is to achieve a ‘balance of probabilities’ outcome, whereby each piece adds cumulatively to set out a convincing case. Most commonly, a statutory declaration that clearly confirms a property’s use and occupation over the relevant period(s) will be accepted as good evidence of occupation. Occasionally, some LPAs may query this if the declaration is by a party directly involved in the project. So ‘third party’ evidence is usually stronger. However, being a sworn statement witnessed by a solicitor/notary means that it is difficult for the LPA to simply disregard it as insufficient – unless they hold contradictory information.
Relevant 36month period
To benefit from the ‘offset’, the entire building does not need to be in use, but simply any ‘part’ of the property. As set out in Schedule 1, Part 1, 1(10) – the relevant building “contains a part that has been in lawful use for a continuous period of at least six months within the period of three years ending on the day planning permission first permits the chargeable development”.
The 36month period is not static and differs, depending upon the type of permission achieved. For a formally granted planning permission, the day planning permission first permits the chargeable development is determined by Reg.8(2) as the date of grant and thus the 3-year period ENDS upon the grant of that permission by the LPA.
However, for permitted development (or general consent), as Herod found to their cost, the relevant period is determined in accordance with Reg.8(7) as the day on which the collecting authority receives a notice of chargeable development submitted to it in accordance with Reg. 64 in respect of that development or, if no notice of chargeable development is submitted, the day on which the last person is served with a notice of chargeable development in accordance with Reg. 64A(3) – whereby the LPA would issue the relevant Notice on the developer/owner.
Hence permitted development gives some control to the developer to ‘manage’ the period if required – possibly to secure a temporary or ‘part’ use of the property, sufficient to enable ‘offset’ and so reduce CIL charge. However, if the use has already ceased, delay in submitting the relevant CIL Form 5 (Notice of Chargeable Development) can erode your lawful use such that it no longer achieves at least six months continuous use.
Furthermore, as Herod indicated – it is best to engage with the LPA in advance of commencing works (including demolition – all as s.56(4) TCPA1990) just in case your view is at odds with that of the charging authority; as once commenced the formal CIL challenges are blocked, and so the quantum of CIL unlikely to change.
If CIL is a serious viability issue, then as a last resort (due to time delay and additional costs - planning and design fees, plus interest charges), one could contemplate a new planning application. This may enable the developer to instal a suitable tenant into the existing building(s) that then secures a future offset when that new permission is granted, so long as at least six months occupation has been achieved (and well recorded to evidence such to the LPA in agreeing the CIL position. Proactively considering CIL early in a project’s genesis might also facilitate occupation to safeguard offset, whilst developing the project strategy, site assembly, funding or seeking the relevant planning permission.
Buildings not "in-use"
The CIL Regulations also allow ‘offset’ for other relevant buildings on “retained parts where the intended use following completion of the chargeable development is a use that is able to be carried on lawfully and permanently without further planning permission in that part on the day before planning permission first permits the chargeable development”.
This means that the if the building, or parts of the building, are retained into the proposed development, and the use of the proposed GIA could be lawfully carried out without planning permission having been sought, then the building does not have to meet the ‘in-use’ criteria for the GIA to be taken into account for the calculation of the ‘offset’.
An example might be where a high street retail property disused for say five years has its upper floors converted to residential, but the ground floor is mostly retained for retail purposes. The retained retail GIA would be allowable for offset. The change of use GIA would not be allowable offset.
The premise is simple, however this is one of the more complicated areas of the regulations when the “lawfully and permanently” test is applied and has created one of the more notable CIL case decisions, handed down by the Court of Appeal in R (Giordano Ltd) v London Borough of Camden [2019] EWCA Civ 1544. This is further corroborated by the recent Valuation Office CIL Appeal decision reference: 1893155 published earlier this month, that held the prior residential C3 use of an earlier permission was sufficient to provide ‘offset’ under Schedule 1, Part 1, 1(6) KR(ii) of a subsequent part retrospective permission.
Validation important
Many LPAs across the country default to issuing the CIL Liability Notice without any offset. Some use this as a lever to encourage Form 2 submission (Assumption of Liability); meaning without a Form 2 the Liability Notice defaults to no offset, but with engagement the CIL is calculated in accordance with the approved plans and Form 1, if correct.
Hence simply paying the Liability Notice as issued, without any scrutiny, could mean that you are paying more CIL than necessary!
We have a consistently high level of CIL enquiries each week and have seen and subsequently advised upon a very wide array of CIL issues. We regularly find a simple ‘validation’ review can generate significant savings for clients, by timely assessment and lodging the relevant Review request under Reg.113 and if necessary, progressing the available appeal to the Valuation Office via Reg.114 CIL.
Next steps
Silence from the LPA is no guarantee that your project is not CIL liable! Too many owners have submitted various CIL forms, including self-build applications, and then carried on commencing their project, seemingly unaware that without an explicit acknowledgement or grant of the exemption, they have probably not been actioned and CIL could still result. Only explicit dialogue with the LPA will deliver certainty – whether or not CIL is thought to apply.
E³ Consulting are a market leading firm of Property Taxation Specialists and have advised on CIL since 2014 with projects throughout England and Wales. We have developed a niche for problematic and complex CIL situations with considerable success in mitigating CIL - both for private clients on residential schemes (including Prime and Super Prime) as well as commercial developments including social housing, charity, educational and healthcare uses. We also advise on VAT, Land Remediation Tax Relief (LRTR), Capital Allowances, Repairs & Maintenance and the new Building Safety Levy.
If you would like to discuss any property tax matters or specific queries relating to the above information, then please do contact the team on 0345 230 6450 or [email protected].
Don’t delay – contact one of our team today to explore how we might help you or one of your clients save money, manage risk or avoid costly errors.