- Property professionals unpick the Budget
- RICS CIL Index 2025 Announcement
- Elliott makes a difference
- E3 Consulting wins 'Best Independent Tax Consultancy Firm'
- SPA Annual Golf Day 2024
- We will be at the South East Construction Expo
- Finalist in 2024 Taxation Awards
- Planning Enforcement Changes to take effect from 25 April 2024 - LURA2023
- Spring Budget 2024
- Pilgrim's Progress: VOA Appeal Decision
- Deadline looming for registration of Scottish property owners
- Nowhere to hide for Furnished Holiday Let owners
- 100% Full Expensing made permanent
- SPA Clay Shoot 2023
- We are exhibiting at UKREiiF 2023
- Welsh Freeports - The two winning bids are...
- Chancellor announces Full Expensing
- 100% Tax relief confirmed for two Scottish Green Freeports
- Making Your Furnished Holiday Lettings More Profitable
- Happy New Year 2023
- Second U-Turn in Urenco Chemplants Case – Court of Appeal Decision
- How Specialists help to Save through Property Tax
- E3 Consulting on the move in London
- Autumn Statement (November): impact on capital allowances
- December Roundtable - Community Infrastructure Levy & Land Remediation Tax Relief
- E3 goes to top with calls for planning re-think
- The Chancellor’s ‘Mini Budget’ – A Tax Bonfire!
- HM Queen Elizabeth II
- Gardiner v Hertsmere - Court of Appeal Judgment
- E3 Consulting's new main office in Wimborne
- Green light for Freeports
- Buried treasure?
- And the winner is...
- Cavernous divide in ‘plant’ arguments
- And the finalists are…
- E3 Consulting puts property tax on the radar
- Help E3 Consulting grow in a nurturing environment
- Spring Statement 2022 – Real Estate & Construction Update
- E3 joins the dots with Building People
- Property Marketing Awards 2022 – Celebrating 30 years of PMA
- Navigating choppy waters
- E3 helps GPs go green with trailblazing surgery
- CIL – New Research Lays Bare Planning Cost
- Webinar success as spotlight shines on Super-deduction
- CIL appeal win saves householder £22,000
- Business Analyst Flo joins E³
- Budget Day Autumn 2021
- Firing on all cylinders
- LRTR Boost your Tax Savings & Unlocking Toxic Land
- CIL by Numbers!
- Shining the legal spotlight on capital allowances
- UPDATE: 130% Super-deduction to be available for landlords
- Specialist speakers announced for CIL webinar panel discussion
- Happy 18th birthday…to us!
- Land remediation myths cleared up at conference
- E³ Consulting – 18th anniversary
- Tax Day 23 March 2021 … over hyped & under whelming!
- Super-deduction…super insight from E³ Consulting’s webinar
- Budget 2021 – Update – Super Deduction
- Budget 2021 Update – Significant tax breaks for freeports announced
- Budget – 2021 – Small Profit Corporation Tax Rate
- UK FREEPORTS - Will Tax Incentives Fulfil Their Purpose?
- E³ Consulting Support Minstead Trust’s Online Christmas Raffle
- E³ Consulting’s Autumn Property Tax Webinars
- £1m AIA Extension
- Alun Oliver becomes CEDR Accredited Mediator
- Property & Construction Update
- Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) - New Year, new rules!
- Budget 2020 - Wish list for Eco friendly Buildings
- Todd Arnison joins YEP Southampton committee
- Welcome to our Winter update!
- RICS Community Infrastructure Levy Talks
- University Award for Apprentice Todd
- Toasting a Record Year for E3 Consulting
- It was 'Not Too Taxing' for the E3 Team at the SPA Clay Shoot
- Finalist in 2019 Accounting Excellence Awards - Specialist Team of the Year
- Finalist in 2019 Taxation Awards - Best Independent Tax Consultancy Firm
- Celebrating 15 Years in Style
- Consulting Boutiques: A Different Perspective on Consulting
- Studying Modern Languages: what skills do you gain and how are these relevant in work?
- It's all in the Mind
- Capital allowance changes consultation
- International Invasive Weed Conference
- Significant tax savings illuminated at London landmark
- So close for Todd in national award
- Taxing matters for property sector - Seminar 17 October 2018
- National award shortlist for apprentice Todd
- Three top tips for organising a fundraising event - and how these are relevant in business
- Alun takes seat on CLA regional board
- E3's Tax Trappers at it again at the SPA Clay Shoot
- Property Tax Update at Athelhampton House
- Welcome to our New Property Tax Surveyor
- Success at the JCI UK National Convention 2017
- Defeat for Taylor Wimpey on Builder's Block VAT Claim
- Non-Resident Landlords (NRL) to move into Corporation Tax Regime
- Joining JCI Southampton as a Corporate Partner
- Signatory to the RICS Inclusive Employer Quality Mark
- E3 Consulting Sponsors Hampshire Hot Shots!
- S.O.S.! Tackling the Housing Crisis, CIL and Build to Rent
- International Women's Day: Making a Commitment to Diversity and Equal Opportunities
- CPD Property Tax Talks
- Why E3 Consulting Employs Interns
- Re-joining the Dorset Chamber of Commerce & Industry
- Welcoming New Interns to E3's Team
- Sponsorship of Alresford Town Football Club
- Finalist in 2015 Taxation Awards - Tax Consultancy Firm
- University of Warwick's Proactive Support of SME Businesses
- Property Taxation Specialist - Finalist in 2014 Taxation Awards
- VAT Specialist, Martin Scammell, Wins Indirect Tax Award
- Capital allowances claims using sampling for fixtures: HMRC Brief
- Business Property Relief on FHLs
- Victory in the 9th annual Solent Property Tennis Tournament
- Industry Response to HMRC's Capital Allowances proposals
- Winning Partnership with Rose Bowl Plc
- E3 Consulting Wins at Taxation Awards 2011
- E3 Consulting Shortlisted for Lexis Nexis Taxation Awards 2011
- Property Taxation Planning Opportunities - November 2010
- E3 Consulting Crowned Mixed Doubles Tennis Champions!
Shining the legal spotlight on capital allowances
A new ruling has thrown fresh light on the distinction between ‘plant’ and ‘premises’ for capital allowance purposes.
Judges at an Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber) (UT) have ruled in favour of HM Revenues and Customs (HMRC) in a case involving the creation of underground storage cavities for natural gas.
The UT upheld a ruling by a lower court that the cavities were ‘premises’ rather than ‘plant’ – meaning that expenditure did not qualify for a tax deduction under capital allowances.
This case – Cheshire Cavity Storage 1 Limited and EDF Energy (Gas Storage Hole House) Limited v The Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs [2021] UKUT 0050 (TCC) – is the latest in a series of disputes in recent years over the sometimes very fine line between what constitutes ‘plant’ and ‘premises’.
However, it has some clear lessons for any business seeking to optimise capital allowances on their property expenditure….
Background
Broadly speaking, capital allowances are available on ‘plant and machinery’ used within businesses but not for the premises in which a business is carried out. Albeit since the tax periods this case dealt with, the new Structures & Buildings Allowances have been introduced – thereby effectively providing tax relief on all commercial property expenditure, bar some residential uses and land/planning costs that are restricted within the tax legislation.
The definition of ‘machinery’ for capital allowance purposes is fairly straight forward but it is debate over what constitutes ‘plant’ which has caused most confusion and conflict over the years – including here.
The Case
Cheshire Cavity Storage 1 Limited and EDF Energy (Gas Storage Hole House) Limited created underground cavities for the storage of gas from the National Transmission System.
The work involved drilling a borehole into naturally occurring salt rock and injecting water to dissolve the rock, leaving a hole filled with saltwater. Gas was then pumped at high pressure into the cavity and the saltwater expelled.Capital allowances were unsuccessfully claimed by the taxpayers (Cheshire Cavity Storage and EDF) on the expenditure for the leaching and de-brining involved.
On appeal, they argued that an item is plant if it has any function as plant but this was refused by a First Tier Tribunal (FTT) which found that the expenditure incurred did not constitute spending on plant.
The FTT accepted that cavities did have a plant-like function similar to a pump/compressor but that its function as premises was the predominant feature. This meant that the cavities were not classed as plant and capital allowances on the expenditure relating to them was disallowed.
Judges Timothy Herrington and Swami Raghavan upheld the FTT ruling at an Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber).
They drew on long established court cases stretching back over a number of years to determine what constitutes ‘plant’ – including the landmark case of Yarmouth v France decided in 1887 which defined plant as ‘whatever apparatus is used by a businessman for carrying on his business’.
What does this mean?
There can be fine lines in the distinctions between ‘plant’ and ‘premises’ for capital allowances on expenditure.
In this case, the FTT decision did depart from some other established cases but the UT made a strong case in upholding this stance in a detailed 22-page ruling which cited case law chronologically dating back more than a century.
It may be that Cheshire Cavity Storage 1 Limited and EDF Energy (Gas Storage Hole House) Limited v The Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs [2021] UKUT 0050 (TCC) becomes a landmark case in years to come.
However, the arguments and costly legal action is sure to continue which is why specialist advice about capital allowances should be taken as early as possible – especially in complex project situations or for innovative buildings and technologies at the boundaries of established law.
Further action
If you would like to discuss this case decision or wider Capital Allowances queries with one of our team, do get in touch as soon as possible. Early advice on any matter should provide an ability to discuss the most comprehensive options available in moving your project forward and achieving the optimal tax savings potentially available.
If you have any property tax issues please do get in touch for a no obligation discussion. You can phone the team on 0345 230 6450 or email hello@e3consulting.co.uk.